Оценка торговых издержек, влияния на рынок и ёмкости стратегии
Сводка
Этот общий аналитический модуль описывает способы оценки торговых издержек для разных классов активов. Он включает оценки спреда между ценами покупки и продажи по диапазону максимум-минимум и автоковариации доходности, скользящие средние объёма и регрессионные подходы для калибровки влияния на рынок по формуле квадратного корня и коэффициента ценового влияния Kyle. Также рассчитывается валовая альфа, необходимая для покрытия издержек, связанных с оборотом, и объём активов под управлением, при котором расчётное влияние на рынок поглощает ожидаемую альфу.
Модуль объединяет эти оценки с заданными таблицами комиссий и стандартизированным сравнением торговых издержек для акций, ETF, бессрочных криптоконтрактов, фьючерсов, FX и опционов. В некоторых процедурах применяются фильтры данных или минимальное число наблюдений, а оценки спреда опираются на предположения о формировании внутридневных цен или эффекте колебаний цены между ценами покупки и продажи. Оценки ёмкости зависят от калиброванного коэффициента влияния, ожидаемой альфы, оборота и ограничений на долю участия в объёме. Эти функции дают инструменты измерения и упрощённые модели; в документе нет эмпирической проверки того, что оценки применимы к конкретному инструменту, площадке или торговому режиму.
Ключевые идеи
- Диапазон между максимумом и минимумом и серийная ковариация доходности дают альтернативные способы оценить спред между ценами покупки и продажи.
- Для калибровки влияния по формуле квадратного корня можно связать абсолютную доходность, масштабированную на волатильность, с квадратным корнем из отношения объёма к среднему объёму.
- Устойчивая регрессия изменения цены на знаковый поток заявок позволяет оценить коэффициент влияния в духе Kyle.
- Расчётная ёмкость зависит от альфы, рыночного объёма, оборота, ограничений на долю участия и влияния на рынок.
- Таблицы комиссий и стандартизированные торговые сравнения помогают привести издержки к общей базе.
Теги
Полный текст
# _cost_analysis.py
```py
"""Shared transaction cost analysis for Ch18 notebooks and case study costs.py.
Provides:
- corwin_schultz_spread(): High-low spread estimator (Corwin & Schultz 2012)
- roll_spread(): Serial covariance spread estimator (Roll 1984)
- compute_adv(): Rolling average daily volume
- compute_adv_usd(): Rolling average daily dollar volume
- calibrate_sqrt_impact(): Fit η in Impact = σ·η·√(Q/V)
- estimate_kyle_lambda(): Linear price-impact coefficient ΔP = λQ
- estimate_capacity(): Max AUM given impact coefficient and alpha
- breakeven_alpha(): Required gross alpha given turnover and costs
- get_fee_schedule(): Codified exchange fee schedules
All functions operate on Polars Series/DataFrames.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import numpy as np
import polars as pl
# =============================================================================
# SPREAD ESTIMATION
# =============================================================================
def corwin_schultz_spread(
high: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
low: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
window: int = 1,
) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
"""Corwin-Schultz (2012) high-low spread estimator.
Estimates the bid-ask spread from daily high and low prices using the
insight that daily highs (lows) are predominantly at ask (bid) prices.
The two-period estimator uses:
β = E[ln(H/L)²] over consecutive single periods
γ = ln(H₂/L₂)² where H₂, L₂ are 2-period high/low
α = (√2β - √β) / (3 - 2√2) - √(γ / (3 - 2√2))
Spread S = 2(eᵅ - 1) / (1 + eᵅ)
Args:
high: High prices (Series or Expr)
low: Low prices (Series or Expr)
window: Rolling window for averaging β (default 1 = raw estimator)
Returns:
Estimated spread as fraction (not bps). Negative values clamped to 0.
"""
ln_hl = (high / low).log()
ln_hl_sq = ln_hl**2
# β: average of sum of consecutive single-period squared log ranges
beta = ln_hl_sq + ln_hl_sq.shift(1)
# γ: squared log range over 2-period high/low
high_2 = high.rolling_max(2)
low_2 = low.rolling_min(2)
gamma = (high_2 / low_2).log() ** 2
if window > 1:
beta = beta.rolling_mean(window)
gamma = gamma.rolling_mean(window)
# α coefficient
denom = 3 - 2 * np.sqrt(2) # ≈ 0.1716
alpha = (((2 * beta).sqrt() - beta.sqrt()) / denom) - (gamma / denom).sqrt()
# Spread = 2(eᵅ - 1) / (1 + eᵅ)
exp_alpha = alpha.exp()
spread = 2 * (exp_alpha - 1) / (1 + exp_alpha)
# Clamp negatives to zero
return spread.clip(lower_bound=0)
def roll_spread(close: pl.Series | pl.Expr, window: int = 20) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
"""Roll (1984) serial covariance spread estimator.
If the bid-ask bounce is the dominant source of serial correlation in
returns, then: Spread = 2√(-Cov(Δpₜ, Δpₜ₋₁))
Only defined when autocovariance is negative (efficient market condition).
Args:
close: Closing prices
window: Rolling window for covariance estimation
Returns:
Estimated spread as fraction. Returns 0 where cov > 0.
"""
ret = close.pct_change()
ret_lag = ret.shift(1)
# Rolling covariance: Cov(rₜ, rₜ₋₁)
# Using: Cov(X,Y) = E[XY] - E[X]E[Y]
cov = (ret * ret_lag).rolling_mean(window) - ret.rolling_mean(window) * ret_lag.rolling_mean(
window
)
# Spread = 2 * sqrt(-cov) where cov < 0, else 0
neg_cov = (-cov).clip(lower_bound=0)
return 2 * neg_cov.sqrt()
# =============================================================================
# VOLUME & IMPACT
# =============================================================================
def compute_adv(volume: pl.Series | pl.Expr, window: int = 20) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
"""Rolling average daily volume (shares/contracts)."""
return volume.rolling_mean(window)
def compute_adv_usd(
volume: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
close: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
window: int = 20,
) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
"""Rolling average daily dollar volume."""
return (volume * close).rolling_mean(window)
def calibrate_sqrt_impact(
returns: np.ndarray,
volume: np.ndarray,
sigma: np.ndarray,
adv: np.ndarray,
*,
min_adv: float = 1e3,
) -> dict:
"""Calibrate η in the square-root impact model: |r| = σ · η · √(V/ADV).
Uses OLS regression of |r|/σ on √(V/ADV) to estimate η.
Args:
returns: Daily returns
volume: Daily volume
sigma: Rolling volatility (same frequency as returns)
adv: Average daily volume
min_adv: Minimum ADV filter to avoid division by near-zero
Returns:
dict with keys: eta, r_squared, std_err, n_obs
"""
from sklearn.linear_model import LinearRegression
# Filter valid observations
mask = (
np.isfinite(returns)
& np.isfinite(volume)
& np.isfinite(sigma)
& np.isfinite(adv)
& (sigma > 0)
& (adv > min_adv)
)
r = np.abs(returns[mask])
s = sigma[mask]
v = volume[mask]
a = adv[mask]
if len(r) < 30:
return {"eta": np.nan, "r_squared": np.nan, "std_err": np.nan, "n_obs": len(r)}
# y = |r| / σ, x = √(V / ADV)
y = r / s
x = np.sqrt(v / a).reshape(-1, 1)
reg = LinearRegression(fit_intercept=False)
reg.fit(x, y)
y_pred = reg.predict(x)
ss_res = np.sum((y - y_pred) ** 2)
ss_tot = np.sum((y - y.mean()) ** 2)
r_squared = 1 - ss_res / ss_tot if ss_tot > 0 else 0.0
n = len(y)
std_err = np.sqrt(ss_res / (n - 1)) / np.sqrt(np.sum(x**2)) if n > 1 else np.nan
return {
"eta": float(reg.coef_[0]),
"r_squared": float(r_squared),
"std_err": float(std_err),
"n_obs": n,
}
def estimate_kyle_lambda(
price_changes: np.ndarray,
signed_volume: np.ndarray,
) -> dict:
"""Estimate Kyle's lambda: ΔP = λ · Q + ε.
Uses HuberRegressor for robustness to outliers.
Args:
price_changes: Price changes (ΔP)
signed_volume: Signed order flow (Q, positive = buy-initiated)
Returns:
dict with keys: lambda_, r_squared, std_err, n_obs
"""
from sklearn.linear_model import HuberRegressor
mask = np.isfinite(price_changes) & np.isfinite(signed_volume) & (signed_volume != 0)
dp = price_changes[mask]
sv = signed_volume[mask].reshape(-1, 1)
if len(dp) < 30:
return {"lambda_": np.nan, "r_squared": np.nan, "std_err": np.nan, "n_obs": len(dp)}
reg = HuberRegressor(fit_intercept=True)
reg.fit(sv, dp)
y_pred = reg.predict(sv)
ss_res = np.sum((dp - y_pred) ** 2)
ss_tot = np.sum((dp - dp.mean()) ** 2)
r_squared = 1 - ss_res / ss_tot if ss_tot > 0 else 0.0
n = len(dp)
std_err = (
np.sqrt(ss_res / (n - 2)) / np.sqrt(np.sum((sv - sv.mean()) ** 2)) if n > 2 else np.nan
)
return {
"lambda_": float(reg.coef_[0]),
"r_squared": float(r_squared),
"std_err": float(std_err),
"n_obs": n,
}
# =============================================================================
# CAPACITY & BREAKEVEN
# =============================================================================
def estimate_capacity(
adv_usd: float,
impact_coeff: float,
gross_alpha_bps: float,
turnover: float = 1.0,
max_participation: float = 0.01,
) -> dict:
"""Estimate strategy capacity (maximum AUM).
A strategy's capacity is limited by market impact eating into gross alpha.
At max AUM, net alpha ≈ 0.
Uses: Impact_bps ≈ impact_coeff * 10_000 * √(trade_$ / ADV_$)
where trade_$ = AUM * turnover * max_participation
Args:
adv_usd: Average daily dollar volume of the universe
impact_coeff: Calibrated η from sqrt impact model
gross_alpha_bps: Expected gross alpha in bps per rebalance
turnover: One-way turnover per rebalance (fraction)
max_participation: Maximum volume participation rate
Returns:
dict with max_aum_usd, breakeven_participation, impact_at_max_bps
"""
if impact_coeff <= 0 or gross_alpha_bps <= 0 or adv_usd <= 0:
return {"max_aum_usd": 0.0, "breakeven_participation": 0.0, "impact_at_max_bps": 0.0}
# Solve: gross_alpha_bps = impact_coeff * 10_000 * sqrt(participation)
# => participation = (gross_alpha_bps / (impact_coeff * 10_000))²
breakeven_participation = (gross_alpha_bps / (impact_coeff * 10_000)) ** 2
breakeven_participation = min(breakeven_participation, max_participation)
# AUM = participation * ADV / turnover
max_aum = breakeven_participation * adv_usd / max(turnover, 1e-6)
impact_at_max = impact_coeff * 10_000 * np.sqrt(breakeven_participation)
return {
"max_aum_usd": float(max_aum),
"breakeven_participation": float(breakeven_participation),
"impact_at_max_bps": float(impact_at_max),
}
def breakeven_alpha(turnover: float, cost_bps: float) -> float:
"""Required gross alpha (as decimal) to break even after costs.
Args:
turnover: Annual one-way turnover (e.g., 12 for monthly rebalance)
cost_bps: Round-trip cost in basis points
Returns:
Required annual gross alpha as decimal (e.g., 0.01 = 1%)
"""
return turnover * cost_bps / 10_000
# =============================================================================
# FEE SCHEDULES
# =============================================================================
FEE_SCHEDULES = {
"us_equities": {
"name": "US Equities (IB Pro)",
"commission_per_share": 0.005,
"min_commission": 1.00,
"sec_fee_per_million": 27.80,
"finra_taf_per_share": 0.000166,
"exchange_rebate_per_share": -0.002, # Maker rebate
"exchange_fee_per_share": 0.003, # Taker fee
"notes": "IB Pro tiered pricing. SEC/FINRA fees on sells only.",
},
"etfs": {
"name": "ETFs (IB Pro)",
"commission_per_share": 0.005,
"min_commission": 1.00,
"sec_fee_per_million": 27.80,
"notes": "Same as equities. Commission-free at some brokers.",
},
"crypto_perps": {
"name": "Crypto Perpetuals (Binance)",
"taker_bps": 4.0,
"maker_bps": 2.0,
"funding_rate_note": "8h funding rate (not a trading cost)",
"notes": "Binance USDT-M futures. VIP tiers reduce fees.",
},
"cme_futures": {
"name": "CME Futures",
"commission_per_contract": 2.00,
"exchange_fee_per_contract": 1.50,
"nfa_fee_per_contract": 0.02,
"clearing_fee_per_contract": 0.10,
"notes": "CME Group all-in costs. Varies by product.",
},
"fx_spot": {
"name": "FX Spot (OANDA-style)",
"spread_bps_major": 1.5,
"spread_bps_cross": 4.0,
"commission_bps": 0.0,
"swap_points_note": "Overnight roll cost varies by pair and direction",
"notes": "Spread-only pricing. No separate commission.",
},
"sp500_options": {
"name": "US Equity Options (IB Pro)",
"commission_per_contract": 0.65,
"min_commission": 1.00,
"exchange_fee_per_contract": 0.30,
"occ_fee_per_contract": 0.055,
"notes": "Options Clearing Corporation + exchange fees.",
},
}
def get_fee_schedule(asset_class: str) -> dict:
"""Get codified fee schedule for an asset class.
Args:
asset_class: One of 'us_equities', 'etfs', 'crypto_perps',
'cme_futures', 'fx_spot', 'sp500_options'
Returns:
Dict with fee components and notes
"""
if asset_class not in FEE_SCHEDULES:
available = ", ".join(sorted(FEE_SCHEDULES.keys()))
raise ValueError(f"Unknown asset class '{asset_class}'. Available: {available}")
return FEE_SCHEDULES[asset_class]
def standardized_cost_per_100k(asset_class: str, price: float = 50.0) -> dict:
"""Estimate total cost for a $100K trade by asset class.
Useful for cross-asset comparison. Returns cost breakdown in bps.
Args:
asset_class: Fee schedule key
price: Representative price per unit (for per-share fees)
Returns:
dict with commission_bps, exchange_bps, total_bps
"""
trade_usd = 100_000
fees = get_fee_schedule(asset_class)
if asset_class in ("us_equities", "etfs"):
shares = trade_usd / price
commission = max(shares * fees["commission_per_share"], fees["min_commission"])
exchange = shares * fees.get("exchange_fee_per_share", 0.003)
sec = (trade_usd / 1e6) * fees.get("sec_fee_per_million", 27.80)
total = commission + exchange + sec
elif asset_class == "crypto_perps":
total = trade_usd * fees["taker_bps"] / 10_000
commission = total
exchange = 0
elif asset_class == "cme_futures":
# Representative CME contract: median notional ~$75K across product mix
# (e.g., E-mini ES ~$260K, corn ~$23K, crude ~$70K, gold ~$230K)
contracts = trade_usd / 75_000
per_contract = (
fees["commission_per_contract"]
+ fees["exchange_fee_per_contract"]
+ fees["nfa_fee_per_contract"]
+ fees["clearing_fee_per_contract"]
)
total = contracts * per_contract
commission = contracts * fees["commission_per_contract"]
exchange = total - commission
elif asset_class == "fx_spot":
total = trade_usd * fees["spread_bps_major"] / 10_000
commission = 0
exchange = total
elif asset_class == "sp500_options":
# Assume ATM option at $5 premium, 100 shares per contract
contracts = trade_usd / 500 # $5 * 100
per_contract = (
fees["commission_per_contract"]
+ fees["exchange_fee_per_contract"]
+ fees["occ_fee_per_contract"]
)
total = contracts * per_contract
commission = contracts * fees["commission_per_contract"]
exchange = total - commission
else:
return {"commission_bps": 0, "exchange_bps": 0, "total_bps": 0}
total_bps = total / trade_usd * 10_000
commission_bps = commission / trade_usd * 10_000
exchange_bps = (total - commission) / trade_usd * 10_000
return {
"commission_bps": round(float(commission_bps), 2),
"exchange_bps": round(float(exchange_bps), 2),
"total_bps": round(float(total_bps), 2),
}
```Полный текст с указанием источника опубликован на условиях его лицензии. Лицензия: MIT
Это краткое изложение подготовлено исследовательским агентом Stratmill по оригиналу и не является его копией.