مواد پر جائیں
لائبریری کی تمام دستاویزات

بیک ٹیسٹ انجن کی مساوات کے آڈٹ قواعد اور شواہد

کوڈ Machine Learning for Trading

خلاصہ

یہ آڈٹ ریکارڈ متعین کرتا ہے کہ حقیقی اسٹریٹیجی کیس اسٹڈیز اور مصنوعی دباؤ کے کام پر ML4T سے کئی بیک ٹیسٹنگ فریم ورکس کا موازنہ کیسے کیا جاتا ہے۔ یہ ترتیب وار فلز، ٹائم اسٹیمپس، اکاؤنٹ کی مالیاتی قدروں، مقداروں اور دیگر عددی فیلڈز کے موازنے کے قواعد بتاتا ہے۔ اس میں فریم ورک کے ایڈیشنز، ناقابلِ تغیر شناختیں، معاونت کی حالت، کارکردگی کی پالیسیاں اور درستگی، دورانیے اور پیمانے کے شواہد کے حوالے بھی درج ہیں۔ دورانیے کی پیمائش صرف انجن کال تک محدود ہے؛ اِن پٹ لوڈ کرنا، پیش گوئی، تیاری، نتائج نکالنا اور رپورٹنگ شامل نہیں۔

ریکارڈ واضح کرتے ہیں کہ مساوات کے دعوے ہر اثاثہ ماڈل اور نفاذ کے دائرے تک محدود ہونے چاہئیں۔ مثال کے طور پر، VectorBT OSS کو CME فیوچرز کے کام کے لیے غیر معاون قرار دیا گیا ہے کیونکہ اس میں مقامی معاہداتی ملٹی پلائرز اور مارجن حساب موجود نہیں، جبکہ VectorBT کے دونوں ایڈیشنز کرپٹو پرپیچوئل فنڈنگ اور مارجن حساب کے لیے غیر معاون ہیں۔ آڈٹ کے دورانیے الگ تھلگ پراسیسز اور درستگی کی جانچ پاس کرنے والے جوڑوں پر مبنی ہیں، اس لیے یہ مختلف ڈیٹا سیٹس یا مشینوں پر عمومی کارکردگی ثابت نہیں کرتے۔ یہ فائل شواہد اور پالیسی کی دستاویز ہے، ٹریڈنگ اشارہ یا تخصیص اسٹریٹیجی کی تعلیم نہیں۔

اہم خیالات

  • بیک ٹیسٹ کی مساوات کا انحصار فلز کی ترتیب، ٹائم اسٹیمپس اور عددی برداشت کی واضح حدوں پر ہے۔
  • دورانیے کے شواہد انجن کالز تک محدود ہیں؛ ڈیٹا اور اڈاپٹر کی تیاری اور نتائج کا انتظام شامل نہیں۔
  • فریم ورک کی معاونت کو اثاثے کے حسابی تقاضوں کے مطابق جانچنا چاہیے۔
  • آڈٹ شائع شدہ دورانیے کے موازنوں کو انہی فریم ورک اور کیس اسٹڈی جوڑوں تک محدود رکھتا ہے جو درستگی کی جانچ پاس کرتے ہیں۔
  • درج شدہ کاموں کے نتائج عمومی رفتار کی درجہ بندی ثابت نہیں کرتے۔

ٹیگز

مکمل متن
# framework_parity_audit.json


```json
{
  "audit_generated_at": "2026-09-03T11:44:14.344493+00:00",
  "comparison_policy": {
    "account_money_fields": [
      "cash",
      "commission",
      "equity",
      "final_value"
    ],
    "account_money_quantum": "0.01",
    "fill_order": "canonical timestamp, asset, side, quantity, price, commission",
    "meaning": "account-money gaps round to zero cents; quantity gaps round to zero at 1e-5 shares or contracts; all other numeric gaps round to zero at 1e-8",
    "quantity_quantum": "0.00001",
    "record_numeric_quantum": "0.00000001",
    "rounding": "ROUND_HALF_EVEN",
    "timestamp_domain": {
      "cme_futures": "session date",
      "crypto_perps_funding": "exact UTC event timestamp",
      "etfs": "session date",
      "fx_pairs": "session date",
      "us_equities_panel": "session date"
    }
  },
  "engine_commit": "7034236519cc0a99df6ef34a21d07ec2a81fc87c",
  "engine_source_sha256": "8011ecdaf90807b4fe4fb5ada518a237311774b32891179bf1fad0a0baad8a58",
  "evidence": {
    "correctness": "https://github.com/ml4t/backtest/blob/0c3de46b1881ce6cb9fd72b672a1dba38ebc383b/validation/REAL_STRATEGY_RESULTS.json",
    "performance": "https://github.com/ml4t/backtest/blob/0c3de46b1881ce6cb9fd72b672a1dba38ebc383b/validation/REAL_STRATEGY_PERFORMANCE.json",
    "source_artifacts": [
      {
        "path": "validation/REAL_STRATEGY_RESULTS.json",
        "sha256": "d7c6460fcb5ebf9ecf74c31d06e227996c66f488de46a5beaa2145104209916b"
      },
      {
        "path": "validation/REAL_STRATEGY_PERFORMANCE.json",
        "sha256": "7276dfba4356c4ce2e6e45c256e4431a4e01cd47ca5710e9d341893286929c40"
      },
      {
        "path": "validation/LARGE_SCALE_RESULTS.json",
        "sha256": "fb3a06a7c485bfb131dfef286ff743af18fa4ba673f5f1075245d7a9123cb3f5"
      }
    ],
    "synthetic_stress": "https://github.com/ml4t/backtest/blob/0c3de46b1881ce6cb9fd72b672a1dba38ebc383b/validation/LARGE_SCALE_RESULTS.json"
  },
  "frameworks": {
    "backtrader": {
      "access": "public",
      "artifact": "backtrader-1.9.78.123-py2.py3-none-any.whl",
      "display_name": "Backtrader",
      "environment": ".venv-backtrader",
      "immutable_id": "sha256:9a07a516b0de9155539a35c56e9404d8711dd7020b3d37b30495e83e1b9d5dfd",
      "license": "GPL-3.0-or-later",
      "package": "backtrader",
      "profile": "backtrader_strict",
      "python": "3.12 audit interpreter; upstream package metadata does not declare a range",
      "python_env_var": "ML4T_BACKTRADER_PYTHON",
      "required_scenarios": 17,
      "scenario_matrix": true,
      "source": "https://pypi.org/project/backtrader/1.9.78.123/",
      "unsupported_scenarios": 0,
      "version": "1.9.78.123"
    },
    "lean": {
      "access": "public",
      "artifact": "quantconnect/lean@sha256:ecd62b0e418d40d1d7c0cd95e90a94e397642a21d2c8810614830c8a4e9a8f70",
      "cli_immutable_id": "sha256:eaa4c08f16295b76f005e429d9ca0d0453784dc1a40c1f5cbe5e50c02a05bd7c",
      "cli_version": "1.0.228",
      "display_name": "LEAN",
      "environment": ".venv-lean",
      "immutable_id": "sha256:ecd62b0e418d40d1d7c0cd95e90a94e397642a21d2c8810614830c8a4e9a8f70",
      "license": "Apache-2.0",
      "package": "lean",
      "platform_artifact": "linux/amd64@sha256:cbe3f26b3f16c57be836b2cf913253d434f58e010c84ed038360d26b9df88307",
      "profile": "lean",
      "python": "3.11",
      "python_env_var": "ML4T_LEAN_PYTHON",
      "required_scenarios": 0,
      "scenario_matrix": false,
      "source": "https://github.com/QuantConnect/Lean",
      "source_commit": "278fcb3d1b815b63ccadba68d7ae54422e34b792",
      "unsupported_scenarios": 0,
      "version": "18001"
    },
    "vectorbt_oss": {
      "access": "public",
      "artifact": "vectorbt-1.1.0.tar.gz",
      "display_name": "VectorBT OSS",
      "environment": ".venv-vectorbt-oss",
      "immutable_id": "sha256:67a3b41466234485af70c18d201da105f1ebb2c1d1fac079db20059e45ddc73b",
      "license": "Apache-2.0 WITH Commons-Clause",
      "package": "vectorbt",
      "profile": "vectorbt_oss_strict",
      "python": ">=3.11,<3.15",
      "python_env_var": "ML4T_VECTORBT_OSS_PYTHON",
      "required_scenarios": 16,
      "scenario_matrix": true,
      "source": "https://pypi.org/project/vectorbt/1.1.0/",
      "source_commit": "259d2d89fe2e7638baf3ca76c394937cd32b656d",
      "unsupported_scenarios": 1,
      "version": "1.1.0"
    },
    "vectorbt_pro": {
      "access": "licensed",
      "display_name": "VectorBT Pro",
      "environment": ".venv-vectorbt-pro",
      "immutable_id": "git:6e18cf0aa37849cfc20848f40f1d26ecfdc771b4",
      "license": "Proprietary",
      "package": "vectorbtpro",
      "profile": "vectorbt_strict",
      "python": ">=3.11",
      "python_env_var": "ML4T_VECTORBT_PRO_PYTHON",
      "required_scenarios": 17,
      "scenario_matrix": true,
      "source": "https://github.com/polakowo/vectorbt.pro",
      "source_commit": "6e18cf0aa37849cfc20848f40f1d26ecfdc771b4",
      "unsupported_scenarios": 0,
      "version": "2026.6.27"
    },
    "zipline": {
      "access": "public",
      "artifact": "zipline_reloaded-3.1.1.tar.gz",
      "display_name": "Zipline Reloaded",
      "environment": ".venv-zipline",
      "immutable_id": "sha256:4a305524616f7aad836f929e5a2ba5afc7db0e238757f47eb49487d9e2457a6f",
      "license": "Apache-2.0",
      "package": "zipline-reloaded",
      "profile": "zipline_strict",
      "python": ">=3.10",
      "python_env_var": "ML4T_ZIPLINE_PYTHON",
      "required_scenarios": 16,
      "scenario_matrix": true,
      "source": "https://pypi.org/project/zipline-reloaded/3.1.1/",
      "source_commit": "09885a2ebc7567d40942c891b3879dc03c745070",
      "unsupported_scenarios": 1,
      "version": "3.1.1"
    }
  },
  "library_commit": "0c3de46b1881ce6cb9fd72b672a1dba38ebc383b",
  "performance_policy": {
    "boundary": "engine call only",
    "excluded": [
      "input loading",
      "model inference",
      "target construction",
      "adapter preparation",
      "result extraction",
      "serialization",
      "reporting"
    ],
    "interval": "10,000-draw percentile bootstrap of the sample median",
    "measured_processes": 10,
    "process_isolation": true,
    "publication_scope": "only correctness-passing case-study/framework pairs",
    "warmup_processes": 1
  },
  "performance_records": [
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.28554552848800085,
        0.2885417409997899
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.2872375610168092,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 0.6924827859284183,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.4141692244884325,
        0.41945260000647977
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.4147937925008591
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.17068579950137064,
        0.17357376401196234
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.17132284450053703,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 0.4124410450618539,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.41297478799242526,
        0.41699278698069975
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.4153874754993012
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        9.30285160850326,
        9.423639220010955
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 9.355300096503925,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 21.7615755934312,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.42605314050160814,
        0.431600633499329
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.4298999425082002
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "framework": "zipline",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        3.8670725979900453,
        3.9098115700180642
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 3.8715068249875912,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 6.126579592244658,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.6284003740001936,
        0.6377887904964155
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.6319197794946376
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "framework": "lean",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        2.4874195760057773,
        2.599079799008905
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 2.564114402513951,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 3.418485618498456,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.7486901020165533,
        0.7566314754949417
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.750073186980444
    },
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.28389174649782944,
        0.2887275889952434
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.28636373148765415,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 0.6631588833815962,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.428688713509473,
        0.43454156002553646
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.43181768149952404
    },
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        2.487967457011109,
        2.526018163494882
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 2.494809443000122,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 5.811638815571466,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.4273611745011294,
        0.4325851899920963
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.4292781300027855
    },
    {
      "case_study": "crypto_perps_funding",
      "framework": "lean",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        2.7094629269995494,
        2.8912153329874855
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 2.801038935489487,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 4.266156698399411,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.6548837659938727,
        0.6614908079791348
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.6565719764912501
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.2809414380026283,
        0.28584351851895917
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.28271306499664206,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 1.9393634353319569,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.14505504499538802,
        0.14667728898348287
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.1457762170030037
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.13754021801287308,
        0.1413268009928288
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.1387957935075974,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 0.9517668155264412,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.1447887455142336,
        0.14715092899859883
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.14582962049462367
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.4199030729942024,
        0.43193558798520826
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.42490502599684987,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 2.919662876838548,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.14518085900635924,
        0.14739416650263593
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.1455322220135713
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "framework": "lean",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.8773026489943732,
        0.9533085440052673
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.9130055215064203,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 5.951507252400165,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        0.1521106895088451,
        0.15719534500385635
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 0.1534074450028129
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        0.7874248115113005,
        0.8377640749968123
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 0.7949095129879424,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 0.03867173809347579,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        20.48596853449999,
        20.599761563003995
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 20.555308661496383
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        16.959977449994767,
        17.023569879005663
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 16.9949149099848,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 0.8292416699730313,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        20.453040241001872,
        20.533734439013642
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 20.49452593299793
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        494.2269169654901,
        510.27303914300865
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 495.55252874150756,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 23.08159898786381,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        21.38583242200548,
        21.54328417198849
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 21.46959268298815
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "framework": "zipline",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        106.83352753649524,
        109.14979357349512
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 107.60890489349549,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 4.862239476470224,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        22.08169161299884,
        22.23382121999748
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 22.131551811515237
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "framework": "lean",
      "framework_ci95_seconds": [
        47.33300897400477,
        48.01486862101592
      ],
      "framework_median_seconds": 47.68267791901599,
      "framework_to_ml4t_ratio": 1.8083761067475683,
      "ml4t_ci95_seconds": [
        26.22179457700986,
        26.472655913996277
      ],
      "ml4t_median_seconds": 26.36767746548867
    }
  ],
  "protocol_scope": {
    "disabled_on_both_sides": [
      "transaction costs",
      "position rules"
    ],
    "shared_inputs": "frozen model-derived targets and historical market data",
    "tested": [
      "target sizing",
      "order sequencing",
      "fills",
      "cash and margin",
      "funding where applicable",
      "valuation"
    ]
  },
  "real_strategy_records": [
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 2466,
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "01f38079ce47821a5379d3769e86f4a2170b88033108153bfc0f928698e946db",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1995
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 2466,
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "01f38079ce47821a5379d3769e86f4a2170b88033108153bfc0f928698e946db",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_oss_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1995
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 2433,
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "01f38079ce47821a5379d3769e86f4a2170b88033108153bfc0f928698e946db",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "backtrader_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1995
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 2458,
      "framework": "zipline",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "01f38079ce47821a5379d3769e86f4a2170b88033108153bfc0f928698e946db",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "zipline_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1995
    },
    {
      "case_study": "etfs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 2457,
      "framework": "lean",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "01f38079ce47821a5379d3769e86f4a2170b88033108153bfc0f928698e946db",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "lean",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1995
    },
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000010",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 3545,
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "c7191027f550ef1be0c9528dac08e7c2bf6a76c86d935f593efeb1ad8b628c39",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_futures_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000007",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1595
    },
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000015",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 3376,
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "c7191027f550ef1be0c9528dac08e7c2bf6a76c86d935f593efeb1ad8b628c39",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "backtrader_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000015",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 1595
    },
    {
      "case_study": "crypto_perps_funding",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 8408,
      "framework": "lean",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "2acee3c8542043266e6f9c0dfc9434c95b4469ef6fcaf0556efc569fc9721cdd",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "lean_crypto_future",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 2426
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 279,
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "48922296cea03bfc9867a9c4e1a1d352a0bd54c0b48671e3ca8d1fdddb95d762",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 2108
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 279,
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "48922296cea03bfc9867a9c4e1a1d352a0bd54c0b48671e3ca8d1fdddb95d762",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_oss_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 2108
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 279,
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "48922296cea03bfc9867a9c4e1a1d352a0bd54c0b48671e3ca8d1fdddb95d762",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "backtrader_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 2108
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 279,
      "framework": "lean",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "48922296cea03bfc9867a9c4e1a1d352a0bd54c0b48671e3ca8d1fdddb95d762",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "lean",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000000",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 2108
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00001950",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 54295,
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "02926d8a7f1c1f5b4855b2393d1763885288ef64950d5cf521ca96c61f454d88",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00001880",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 4146
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00001910",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 49120,
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "02926d8a7f1c1f5b4855b2393d1763885288ef64950d5cf521ca96c61f454d88",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "vectorbt_oss_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00001870",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 4146
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000170",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 54242,
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "02926d8a7f1c1f5b4855b2393d1763885288ef64950d5cf521ca96c61f454d88",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "backtrader_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000160",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 4146
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000190",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 54259,
      "framework": "zipline",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "02926d8a7f1c1f5b4855b2393d1763885288ef64950d5cf521ca96c61f454d88",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "zipline_strict",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000030",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 4027
    },
    {
      "case_study": "us_equities_panel",
      "equity_gap": "0.00",
      "equity_raw_gap": "0.00000460",
      "fill_gap": "0.00000000",
      "fills": 54265,
      "framework": "lean",
      "input_bundle_sha256": "02926d8a7f1c1f5b4855b2393d1763885288ef64950d5cf521ca96c61f454d88",
      "negative_control_detected": true,
      "profile": "lean",
      "status": "pass",
      "terminal_gap": "0.00",
      "terminal_raw_gap": "0.00000420",
      "valuation_timestamps_match": true,
      "valuations": 4027
    }
  ],
  "schema_version": 2,
  "scope": {
    "case_protocols": {
      "fx_pairs": "USD-quoted pairs from the frozen target stream, preserving native USD valuation in every required engine"
    },
    "case_studies": [
      "etfs",
      "cme_futures",
      "crypto_perps_funding",
      "fx_pairs",
      "us_equities_panel"
    ],
    "frameworks": [
      "vectorbt_pro",
      "vectorbt_oss",
      "backtrader",
      "zipline",
      "lean"
    ],
    "real_strategy_equivalence_gate_passed": true,
    "required_pairs": 17,
    "unsupported_pairs": 8
  },
  "synthetic_stress": {
    "assets": 250,
    "bars": 1260000,
    "comparison_policy": {
      "account_money_quantum": "0.01",
      "record_numeric_quantum": "1E-8"
    },
    "generated_at": "2026-09-03T08:44:03.035191+00:00",
    "records": [
      {
        "fills": 423313,
        "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
        "intents": 427790,
        "status": "pass",
        "terminal_value": 1285886.32,
        "trades": 222751
      },
      {
        "fills": 417941,
        "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
        "intents": 427790,
        "status": "pass",
        "terminal_value": 1345348.85,
        "trades": 211322
      },
      {
        "fills": 343813,
        "framework": "backtrader",
        "intents": 427790,
        "status": "pass",
        "terminal_value": -9166273.56,
        "trades": 182019
      },
      {
        "fills": 427696,
        "framework": "zipline",
        "intents": 427790,
        "status": "pass",
        "terminal_value": 10504095.9,
        "trades": 226434
      },
      {
        "fills": 361297,
        "framework": "lean",
        "intents": 427790,
        "status": "pass",
        "terminal_value": 184538.13,
        "trades": 191297
      }
    ],
    "sessions": 5040,
    "synthetic": true
  },
  "unsupported_records": [
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "reason": "no native futures contract multiplier and margin-account model",
      "source": "https://vectorbt.dev/api/portfolio/base/",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "framework": "zipline",
      "reason": "the frozen workload has continuous root series but no dated contract chain or roll map",
      "source": "https://zipline.ml4trading.io/api-reference.html",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "cme_futures",
      "framework": "lean",
      "reason": "the frozen workload has continuous root series but no dated contract chain or roll map",
      "source": "https://www.quantconnect.com/docs/v2/writing-algorithms/securities/asset-classes/futures",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "crypto_perps_funding",
      "framework": "vectorbt_pro",
      "reason": "no native perpetual-futures funding and margin-account model",
      "source": "https://vectorbt.pro/features/portfolio/",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "crypto_perps_funding",
      "framework": "vectorbt_oss",
      "reason": "no native perpetual-futures funding and margin-account model",
      "source": "https://vectorbt.dev/api/portfolio/base/",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "crypto_perps_funding",
      "framework": "backtrader",
      "reason": "no native perpetual-futures funding model",
      "source": "https://www.backtrader.com/docu/commission-schemes/commission-schemes/",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "crypto_perps_funding",
      "framework": "zipline",
      "reason": "no crypto perpetual-futures asset and funding model",
      "source": "https://zipline.ml4trading.io/api-reference.html",
      "status": "unsupported"
    },
    {
      "case_study": "fx_pairs",
      "framework": "zipline",
      "reason": "no native spot-forex asset, currency cashbook, or conversion model",
      "source": "https://zipline.ml4trading.io/api-reference.html",
      "status": "unsupported"
    }
  ]
}

```

ماخذ کا حوالہ دیتے ہوئے مکمل متن دکھایا گیا ہے، ماخذ کے لائسنس کے تحت۔ لائسنس: MIT

یہ خلاصہ اصل ماخذ سے Stratmill کے تحقیقی ایجنٹ نے لکھا ہے؛ یہ ماخذ کی نقل نہیں۔