Adjusting Portfolio Withdrawals for Inflation in Real Terms
Summary
The note explains how to model a fixed real withdrawal from a portfolio when returns and wealth are represented in nominal terms. It defines real wealth as nominal wealth divided by a price index, then expresses a withdrawal as a fraction of that real wealth. To implement the same withdrawal using nominal wealth, the equivalent nominal withdrawal rate must be scaled by the inverse of the price level.
This means the nominal rate changes over time as inflation accumulates: it falls when the price level rises, while the real withdrawal remains constant relative to inflation-adjusted wealth. The relationship is presented algebraically rather than tested with a simulation or return data. It assumes the relevant price index starts at one and that the goal is to preserve a fixed withdrawal rate against real wealth; other withdrawal policies or timing conventions are not discussed.
Key ideas
- Real wealth is nominal wealth divided by the price level.
- A fixed percentage withdrawal from real wealth can be converted into an equivalent rate applied to nominal wealth.
- The nominal withdrawal rate is the real rate divided by the price index.
- As the price level changes, the nominal rate moves in the opposite direction to keep the real withdrawal consistent.
Tags
Full text
# Accounting for Withdrawals
# Accounting for Withdrawals
I am trying to wrap my head around the proper way to do this. I would like to simulate the portfolio value adjusted for inflation with a fixed withdrawal rate.
To simulate withdrawal rate, I will need to adjust my portfolio nominal return series to real return using CPI. After getting real return series, assume that my fixed withdrawal amount is 5% of initial equity. If my initial equity is, say, $1, then my withdrawal rate is 0.05. Since my simulation is real return based, do I need to adjust my fixed withdrawal rate for inflation or do I just keep it fixed at 0.05 and withdrawal this amount each period?
If I do adjust it, I am using the following equation: if inflation is 1% then current withdrawal rate = 0.05 + (0.05 * 0.01) = 0.0505
Which is correct?
## Answer by John (score 1, accepted)
https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/4159
Let real wealth at time $t$ be defined as $W_{t}^{R}\equiv\frac{W_{t}^{N}}{P_{t}}$ where $W_{t}^{N}$ is nominal wealth and $P_{t}$ is the price level indexed to one at the initial period. You want to withdraw a $x_{t}$ percent of real wealth. This would give $$x_{t}W_{t}^{R}=x_{t}\frac{W_{t}^{N}}{P_{t}}$$.You could then consider a withdrawal rate in nominal terms $y_{t}\equiv\frac{x_{t}}{P_{t}}$ (ie. that you multiply by the nominal wealth) that would effectively mimic the real withdrawal rate. When wealth grows faster than inflation, the nominal withdrawal rate should decline and vice-versa.Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)
This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.