Skip to content
All library documents

Choosing Comparable Funding Rates for Covered Interest Parity Tests

Article Quant Q&A · Author: JohnAndrews

Summary

The document considers which interest rates to use when testing covered interest rate parity between the euro and the US dollar. Its central point is that unsecured interbank rates, such as LIBOR and Euribor, include bank credit risk premia that can differ across regions. Those differences can make the rate relationship appear inconsistent with the forward-to-spot ratio, so the rates may not be suitable for a clean parity comparison.

The response recommends using borrowing and lending rates on a collateralized basis where available. As a practical proxy, it suggests comparing mid quotes on US Treasury bills with German government bills, which it regards as relatively low risk. It also notes that the euro area does not have one sovereign issuer: different euro-denominated government securities can imply different comparisons, and some issuers carry meaningful credit risk. The answer does not provide a data source for bid and ask quotes or a full transaction-cost treatment, and its proxy recommendation depends on the securities’ risk characteristics.

Key ideas

  • Interest rates used in a parity test should reflect comparable funding and investment risks.
  • Unsecured interbank rates can embed differing bank credit premia across currencies.
  • Collateralized rates are preferable when suitable data are available.
  • US Treasury and German government bill mid quotes are offered as a low-risk proxy.
  • Euro-denominated sovereign securities can differ in credit quality, affecting the comparison.

Tags

Full text
# When calculating CIP between EU and US, which interest rates data to use?


# When calculating CIP between EU and US, which interest rates data to use?












I am wondering which data to use to test the Covered Interest Rate Parity between Europe and the United States. Recap that for the CIP to hold, it should mean that

F/S = (1+r)/(1+r*) where

- F = the 1-period ahead forward rate on the EUR/USD exchange rate

- S = the spot rate of the EUR/USD exchange

- r = domestic interest rate

- r* = foreign interest rate

For the forward rate I use the 1-month rates available on many resource sites, this holds true for the spot rate. However, which interest rate should I use for the domestic and foreign one?

My guess was to use the Euribor (1-Month) for the European and the Daily Treasury Yield (1-Month) or the USD Libor (1-Month).

However, then there is a huge gap between F/S and (1+r)/(1+r*); i.e. F/S yields values around 0.9-0.95 whereas (1+r)/(1+r*) yields values around 0.5 (when using USD Libor), meaning that the CIP definitely does not hold.

Recap that the lastest rate on the T-bill (1-Month) equals 0.03 and USD libor 0.1992 whereas the Euribor (1-Month) equals 0.112. Also recap that the forward rate (1-month) on EUR/USD is about 1.25 and the spot rate about 1.31.

An explanation could be of course the absence of transaction costs, but does this explain such a large gap? And secondly, if I wanted to calculate the CIP with transaction costs, does anybody know where to get the BID and ASK quotes on the Euribor and Treasury Bill?

In summary: - Which interest rate should I use for Europe and US? - Why is there such a large gap? - Where to get the BID and ASK quotes on the Euribor and T-bill?

Thank you.

## Answer by Vince (score 1)

https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/7940

stay away from using rates that are based on unsecured funding -- there is differential risk premia embedded if you do, e.g., the health of the US banking system versus that of Europe's when using libor usd versus euribor. also, those rates are liable to manipulation. what you want to use are the rates charged for borrowing in one country versus the rates conferred to lend in another on a collateralized basis. barring the availability of such data, as a proxy using mid quotes on US tbills and mid quotes on german tbills -- both are relatively risk free -- should do the trick (too bad both are near 0, if not negative, as Germany's was until a few months ago.) Also note in this case, because the euro is the currency of so many different countries, each with their own government securities, the Euro/US pair has several associated CIP calculations possible. Though indeed, for many of the countries, the gov securities are not rated anywhere near 'risk free' and therefore cannot be used.

Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)

This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.