Skip to content
All library documents

Economic Claims and Access in Markets for Assets Without Physical Delivery

Article Quant Q&A · Author: Eric Brotto

Summary

The discussion considers whether people can trade shares in assets such as a band or an antique without taking possession. Its central idea is that buyers need a reason to hold a claim, such as a contractual share of revenue, a payout tied to an event, or eventual physical delivery. A band could distribute income from performances or recordings, while a collectible might be held by a custodian as investors trade claims on its value.

Examples include artist funding arrangements and sports event contracts with cash or prize payouts. These illustrate that an exchange can organize trading, but the underlying agreement must define what holders receive and connect their claim to the asset or outcome. The discussion raises legal restrictions as an open question; it does not explain applicable laws, regulatory requirements, valuation, custody, or market design. Its examples are illustrative rather than evidence that any particular structure is broadly available or legally suitable.

Key ideas

  • A tradable claim needs a defined economic benefit or a physical delivery obligation to motivate buyers.
  • Revenue sharing can connect an investment in an artist to income from performances or recordings.
  • Event-linked contracts can pay based on outcomes without representing ownership of the underlying asset.
  • Trading claims on a stored collectible would require a clear arrangement linking the claim to the item and its value.
  • Legal constraints are raised as a concern but are not analyzed in the discussion.

Tags

Full text
# Creating a financial market


# Creating a financial market












Let's say I wanted to create my own financial market where people could buy with real money shares in a real physical product such as, for example, a rock band. If the value of the rock band goes up, so do the investors shares, if the value of the rock band goes down, etc.

Is this feasible? Any links to resources on this?

EDIT 1

I used the example of a rock band because I was inspired by this article, but I think this could apply to virtually anything. People value different things for different reasons. A rock band could be considered valuable because it gives returns on it's revenue, but also maybe just because a fan gives value to 'owning' a share in their favorite artist. Granted a rock band is maybe not the best example, so let's not go too far with this.

How about an antique? This is something that people could make money on if they sell shares in an object whose worth has for whatever reason increased in value since the time of their initial investment.

I was thinking of something similar to ebay, but where the users bid on shares of an object that they never receive. An antique could sit in a museum and the shares could be sold to people who bid on it according to what they think it is currently worth.

EDIT 2

Okay, so there has already been a lot of great comments and answers to this question. And the explanations of the principals of the market system are helpful. But I guess what I was really wondering was if there are any legal limitations. This may be too broad to answer here, but any insights or links to resources would be appreciated.

## Answer by SRKX (score 3)

https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/3130

As Tal Fishman and chrisaycock said in their comments, you need to have a possible economic gain (or a physical delivery) coming from the underlying (in your example a rock band) that motivates the investor to acquire shares.

What you suggest has already been done in France, through the website MyMajorCompany.com where you can buy a "share" of artists (music, comics designers, ...) which will give you the right to claim part of the artist's revenue from a concert, an album, and so on. There is also a website called Private Joke where you can invest in the same way on humorists.

Note that you also have example of exchanges where the underlying is not really a "share" but a possible income in gifts or in money depending on whether an event occurs or not. A well-known example is Betfair, an exchange specialized on sports betting. Eurosport (a European sport TV channel) also had a contest for the football world cup where you could buy "shares" of football teams prior and during the tournament, and where the owners of the winning teams in the end received gifts such as cars or TVs.

If you have not contact with the rock band, or the rock band is not willing to share its shares, you won't really be able to create such an exchange.

Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)

This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.