Skip to content
All library documents

Estimating Trading Costs, Market Impact, and Strategy Capacity

Code Machine Learning for Trading

Summary

This shared analysis module describes ways to estimate trading frictions across asset classes. It includes high-low and return-autocovariance estimators for bid-ask spreads, rolling average volume measures, and regression approaches for calibrating square-root market impact and Kyle’s price-impact coefficient. It also provides calculations for the gross alpha needed to offset turnover-related costs and for the assets under management at which estimated impact consumes expected alpha.

The module combines those estimates with codified fee schedules and a standardized trade-cost comparison across equities, ETFs, crypto perpetuals, futures, FX, and options. Several routines impose data filters or minimum observation counts, and the spread estimators rely on assumptions about intraday price formation or bid-ask bounce. Capacity estimates depend on the calibrated impact coefficient, expected alpha, turnover, and participation limits. These functions offer measurement tools and simplifying models; the document does not supply empirical validation showing that any estimate will generalize to a particular instrument, venue, or trading regime.

Key ideas

  • High-low ranges and serial return covariance provide alternative estimators of bid-ask spreads.
  • Square-root impact can be calibrated by relating volatility-scaled absolute returns to the square root of volume relative to average volume.
  • A robust regression of price changes on signed order flow estimates a Kyle-style impact coefficient.
  • Estimated capacity depends on alpha, market volume, turnover, participation constraints, and impact.
  • Fee schedules and standardized trade comparisons help translate costs into a common basis.

Tags

Full text
# _cost_analysis.py


```py
"""Shared transaction cost analysis for Ch18 notebooks and case study costs.py.

Provides:
- corwin_schultz_spread(): High-low spread estimator (Corwin & Schultz 2012)
- roll_spread(): Serial covariance spread estimator (Roll 1984)
- compute_adv(): Rolling average daily volume
- compute_adv_usd(): Rolling average daily dollar volume
- calibrate_sqrt_impact(): Fit η in Impact = σ·η·√(Q/V)
- estimate_kyle_lambda(): Linear price-impact coefficient ΔP = λQ
- estimate_capacity(): Max AUM given impact coefficient and alpha
- breakeven_alpha(): Required gross alpha given turnover and costs
- get_fee_schedule(): Codified exchange fee schedules

All functions operate on Polars Series/DataFrames.
"""

from __future__ import annotations

import numpy as np
import polars as pl

# =============================================================================
# SPREAD ESTIMATION
# =============================================================================


def corwin_schultz_spread(
    high: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
    low: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
    window: int = 1,
) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
    """Corwin-Schultz (2012) high-low spread estimator.

    Estimates the bid-ask spread from daily high and low prices using the
    insight that daily highs (lows) are predominantly at ask (bid) prices.

    The two-period estimator uses:
        β = E[ln(H/L)²]  over consecutive single periods
        γ = ln(H₂/L₂)²   where H₂, L₂ are 2-period high/low
        α = (√2β - √β) / (3 - 2√2) - √(γ / (3 - 2√2))

    Spread S = 2(eᵅ - 1) / (1 + eᵅ)

    Args:
        high: High prices (Series or Expr)
        low: Low prices (Series or Expr)
        window: Rolling window for averaging β (default 1 = raw estimator)

    Returns:
        Estimated spread as fraction (not bps). Negative values clamped to 0.
    """
    ln_hl = (high / low).log()
    ln_hl_sq = ln_hl**2

    # β: average of sum of consecutive single-period squared log ranges
    beta = ln_hl_sq + ln_hl_sq.shift(1)

    # γ: squared log range over 2-period high/low
    high_2 = high.rolling_max(2)
    low_2 = low.rolling_min(2)
    gamma = (high_2 / low_2).log() ** 2

    if window > 1:
        beta = beta.rolling_mean(window)
        gamma = gamma.rolling_mean(window)

    # α coefficient
    denom = 3 - 2 * np.sqrt(2)  # ≈ 0.1716

    alpha = (((2 * beta).sqrt() - beta.sqrt()) / denom) - (gamma / denom).sqrt()

    # Spread = 2(eᵅ - 1) / (1 + eᵅ)
    exp_alpha = alpha.exp()
    spread = 2 * (exp_alpha - 1) / (1 + exp_alpha)

    # Clamp negatives to zero
    return spread.clip(lower_bound=0)


def roll_spread(close: pl.Series | pl.Expr, window: int = 20) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
    """Roll (1984) serial covariance spread estimator.

    If the bid-ask bounce is the dominant source of serial correlation in
    returns, then: Spread = 2√(-Cov(Δpₜ, Δpₜ₋₁))

    Only defined when autocovariance is negative (efficient market condition).

    Args:
        close: Closing prices
        window: Rolling window for covariance estimation

    Returns:
        Estimated spread as fraction. Returns 0 where cov > 0.
    """
    ret = close.pct_change()
    ret_lag = ret.shift(1)

    # Rolling covariance: Cov(rₜ, rₜ₋₁)
    # Using: Cov(X,Y) = E[XY] - E[X]E[Y]
    cov = (ret * ret_lag).rolling_mean(window) - ret.rolling_mean(window) * ret_lag.rolling_mean(
        window
    )

    # Spread = 2 * sqrt(-cov) where cov < 0, else 0
    neg_cov = (-cov).clip(lower_bound=0)
    return 2 * neg_cov.sqrt()


# =============================================================================
# VOLUME & IMPACT
# =============================================================================


def compute_adv(volume: pl.Series | pl.Expr, window: int = 20) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
    """Rolling average daily volume (shares/contracts)."""
    return volume.rolling_mean(window)


def compute_adv_usd(
    volume: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
    close: pl.Series | pl.Expr,
    window: int = 20,
) -> pl.Series | pl.Expr:
    """Rolling average daily dollar volume."""
    return (volume * close).rolling_mean(window)


def calibrate_sqrt_impact(
    returns: np.ndarray,
    volume: np.ndarray,
    sigma: np.ndarray,
    adv: np.ndarray,
    *,
    min_adv: float = 1e3,
) -> dict:
    """Calibrate η in the square-root impact model: |r| = σ · η · √(V/ADV).

    Uses OLS regression of |r|/σ on √(V/ADV) to estimate η.

    Args:
        returns: Daily returns
        volume: Daily volume
        sigma: Rolling volatility (same frequency as returns)
        adv: Average daily volume
        min_adv: Minimum ADV filter to avoid division by near-zero

    Returns:
        dict with keys: eta, r_squared, std_err, n_obs
    """
    from sklearn.linear_model import LinearRegression

    # Filter valid observations
    mask = (
        np.isfinite(returns)
        & np.isfinite(volume)
        & np.isfinite(sigma)
        & np.isfinite(adv)
        & (sigma > 0)
        & (adv > min_adv)
    )
    r = np.abs(returns[mask])
    s = sigma[mask]
    v = volume[mask]
    a = adv[mask]

    if len(r) < 30:
        return {"eta": np.nan, "r_squared": np.nan, "std_err": np.nan, "n_obs": len(r)}

    # y = |r| / σ,  x = √(V / ADV)
    y = r / s
    x = np.sqrt(v / a).reshape(-1, 1)

    reg = LinearRegression(fit_intercept=False)
    reg.fit(x, y)

    y_pred = reg.predict(x)
    ss_res = np.sum((y - y_pred) ** 2)
    ss_tot = np.sum((y - y.mean()) ** 2)
    r_squared = 1 - ss_res / ss_tot if ss_tot > 0 else 0.0

    n = len(y)
    std_err = np.sqrt(ss_res / (n - 1)) / np.sqrt(np.sum(x**2)) if n > 1 else np.nan

    return {
        "eta": float(reg.coef_[0]),
        "r_squared": float(r_squared),
        "std_err": float(std_err),
        "n_obs": n,
    }


def estimate_kyle_lambda(
    price_changes: np.ndarray,
    signed_volume: np.ndarray,
) -> dict:
    """Estimate Kyle's lambda: ΔP = λ · Q + ε.

    Uses HuberRegressor for robustness to outliers.

    Args:
        price_changes: Price changes (ΔP)
        signed_volume: Signed order flow (Q, positive = buy-initiated)

    Returns:
        dict with keys: lambda_, r_squared, std_err, n_obs
    """
    from sklearn.linear_model import HuberRegressor

    mask = np.isfinite(price_changes) & np.isfinite(signed_volume) & (signed_volume != 0)
    dp = price_changes[mask]
    sv = signed_volume[mask].reshape(-1, 1)

    if len(dp) < 30:
        return {"lambda_": np.nan, "r_squared": np.nan, "std_err": np.nan, "n_obs": len(dp)}

    reg = HuberRegressor(fit_intercept=True)
    reg.fit(sv, dp)

    y_pred = reg.predict(sv)
    ss_res = np.sum((dp - y_pred) ** 2)
    ss_tot = np.sum((dp - dp.mean()) ** 2)
    r_squared = 1 - ss_res / ss_tot if ss_tot > 0 else 0.0

    n = len(dp)
    std_err = (
        np.sqrt(ss_res / (n - 2)) / np.sqrt(np.sum((sv - sv.mean()) ** 2)) if n > 2 else np.nan
    )

    return {
        "lambda_": float(reg.coef_[0]),
        "r_squared": float(r_squared),
        "std_err": float(std_err),
        "n_obs": n,
    }


# =============================================================================
# CAPACITY & BREAKEVEN
# =============================================================================


def estimate_capacity(
    adv_usd: float,
    impact_coeff: float,
    gross_alpha_bps: float,
    turnover: float = 1.0,
    max_participation: float = 0.01,
) -> dict:
    """Estimate strategy capacity (maximum AUM).

    A strategy's capacity is limited by market impact eating into gross alpha.
    At max AUM, net alpha ≈ 0.

    Uses: Impact_bps ≈ impact_coeff * 10_000 * √(trade_$ / ADV_$)
    where trade_$ = AUM * turnover * max_participation

    Args:
        adv_usd: Average daily dollar volume of the universe
        impact_coeff: Calibrated η from sqrt impact model
        gross_alpha_bps: Expected gross alpha in bps per rebalance
        turnover: One-way turnover per rebalance (fraction)
        max_participation: Maximum volume participation rate

    Returns:
        dict with max_aum_usd, breakeven_participation, impact_at_max_bps
    """
    if impact_coeff <= 0 or gross_alpha_bps <= 0 or adv_usd <= 0:
        return {"max_aum_usd": 0.0, "breakeven_participation": 0.0, "impact_at_max_bps": 0.0}

    # Solve: gross_alpha_bps = impact_coeff * 10_000 * sqrt(participation)
    # => participation = (gross_alpha_bps / (impact_coeff * 10_000))²
    breakeven_participation = (gross_alpha_bps / (impact_coeff * 10_000)) ** 2
    breakeven_participation = min(breakeven_participation, max_participation)

    # AUM = participation * ADV / turnover
    max_aum = breakeven_participation * adv_usd / max(turnover, 1e-6)

    impact_at_max = impact_coeff * 10_000 * np.sqrt(breakeven_participation)

    return {
        "max_aum_usd": float(max_aum),
        "breakeven_participation": float(breakeven_participation),
        "impact_at_max_bps": float(impact_at_max),
    }


def breakeven_alpha(turnover: float, cost_bps: float) -> float:
    """Required gross alpha (as decimal) to break even after costs.

    Args:
        turnover: Annual one-way turnover (e.g., 12 for monthly rebalance)
        cost_bps: Round-trip cost in basis points

    Returns:
        Required annual gross alpha as decimal (e.g., 0.01 = 1%)
    """
    return turnover * cost_bps / 10_000


# =============================================================================
# FEE SCHEDULES
# =============================================================================

FEE_SCHEDULES = {
    "us_equities": {
        "name": "US Equities (IB Pro)",
        "commission_per_share": 0.005,
        "min_commission": 1.00,
        "sec_fee_per_million": 27.80,
        "finra_taf_per_share": 0.000166,
        "exchange_rebate_per_share": -0.002,  # Maker rebate
        "exchange_fee_per_share": 0.003,  # Taker fee
        "notes": "IB Pro tiered pricing. SEC/FINRA fees on sells only.",
    },
    "etfs": {
        "name": "ETFs (IB Pro)",
        "commission_per_share": 0.005,
        "min_commission": 1.00,
        "sec_fee_per_million": 27.80,
        "notes": "Same as equities. Commission-free at some brokers.",
    },
    "crypto_perps": {
        "name": "Crypto Perpetuals (Binance)",
        "taker_bps": 4.0,
        "maker_bps": 2.0,
        "funding_rate_note": "8h funding rate (not a trading cost)",
        "notes": "Binance USDT-M futures. VIP tiers reduce fees.",
    },
    "cme_futures": {
        "name": "CME Futures",
        "commission_per_contract": 2.00,
        "exchange_fee_per_contract": 1.50,
        "nfa_fee_per_contract": 0.02,
        "clearing_fee_per_contract": 0.10,
        "notes": "CME Group all-in costs. Varies by product.",
    },
    "fx_spot": {
        "name": "FX Spot (OANDA-style)",
        "spread_bps_major": 1.5,
        "spread_bps_cross": 4.0,
        "commission_bps": 0.0,
        "swap_points_note": "Overnight roll cost varies by pair and direction",
        "notes": "Spread-only pricing. No separate commission.",
    },
    "sp500_options": {
        "name": "US Equity Options (IB Pro)",
        "commission_per_contract": 0.65,
        "min_commission": 1.00,
        "exchange_fee_per_contract": 0.30,
        "occ_fee_per_contract": 0.055,
        "notes": "Options Clearing Corporation + exchange fees.",
    },
}


def get_fee_schedule(asset_class: str) -> dict:
    """Get codified fee schedule for an asset class.

    Args:
        asset_class: One of 'us_equities', 'etfs', 'crypto_perps',
            'cme_futures', 'fx_spot', 'sp500_options'

    Returns:
        Dict with fee components and notes
    """
    if asset_class not in FEE_SCHEDULES:
        available = ", ".join(sorted(FEE_SCHEDULES.keys()))
        raise ValueError(f"Unknown asset class '{asset_class}'. Available: {available}")
    return FEE_SCHEDULES[asset_class]


def standardized_cost_per_100k(asset_class: str, price: float = 50.0) -> dict:
    """Estimate total cost for a $100K trade by asset class.

    Useful for cross-asset comparison. Returns cost breakdown in bps.

    Args:
        asset_class: Fee schedule key
        price: Representative price per unit (for per-share fees)

    Returns:
        dict with commission_bps, exchange_bps, total_bps
    """
    trade_usd = 100_000
    fees = get_fee_schedule(asset_class)

    if asset_class in ("us_equities", "etfs"):
        shares = trade_usd / price
        commission = max(shares * fees["commission_per_share"], fees["min_commission"])
        exchange = shares * fees.get("exchange_fee_per_share", 0.003)
        sec = (trade_usd / 1e6) * fees.get("sec_fee_per_million", 27.80)
        total = commission + exchange + sec
    elif asset_class == "crypto_perps":
        total = trade_usd * fees["taker_bps"] / 10_000
        commission = total
        exchange = 0
    elif asset_class == "cme_futures":
        # Representative CME contract: median notional ~$75K across product mix
        # (e.g., E-mini ES ~$260K, corn ~$23K, crude ~$70K, gold ~$230K)
        contracts = trade_usd / 75_000
        per_contract = (
            fees["commission_per_contract"]
            + fees["exchange_fee_per_contract"]
            + fees["nfa_fee_per_contract"]
            + fees["clearing_fee_per_contract"]
        )
        total = contracts * per_contract
        commission = contracts * fees["commission_per_contract"]
        exchange = total - commission
    elif asset_class == "fx_spot":
        total = trade_usd * fees["spread_bps_major"] / 10_000
        commission = 0
        exchange = total
    elif asset_class == "sp500_options":
        # Assume ATM option at $5 premium, 100 shares per contract
        contracts = trade_usd / 500  # $5 * 100
        per_contract = (
            fees["commission_per_contract"]
            + fees["exchange_fee_per_contract"]
            + fees["occ_fee_per_contract"]
        )
        total = contracts * per_contract
        commission = contracts * fees["commission_per_contract"]
        exchange = total - commission
    else:
        return {"commission_bps": 0, "exchange_bps": 0, "total_bps": 0}

    total_bps = total / trade_usd * 10_000
    commission_bps = commission / trade_usd * 10_000
    exchange_bps = (total - commission) / trade_usd * 10_000

    return {
        "commission_bps": round(float(commission_bps), 2),
        "exchange_bps": round(float(exchange_bps), 2),
        "total_bps": round(float(total_bps), 2),
    }

```

Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: MIT

This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.