Skip to content
All library documents

Expected Log Return for Budgeted Allocation Across Independent Investments

Article Quant Q&A · Author: KaiPai

Summary

The document asks how to allocate a fixed budget across several investment opportunities whose occurrence is independent, whose returns depend on allocated amounts, and whose parameters may be uncertain. It distinguishes this setup from single-bet Kelly sizing and from models of mutually exclusive outcomes, and raises the challenge of making repeated decisions as estimates and available budget change over time.

The answer proposes choosing allocations by maximizing the sum of each opportunity’s probability-weighted log payoff. This gives a compact objective for sizing multiple positions under a budget constraint, but the response is brief and does not derive the expression or specify constraints on allocations and payoffs. It also does not resolve the question’s uncertain parameters, temporal updating, correlations in realized outcomes, or the exact interpretation of “overall expected return.” Those details would need to be clarified before treating the proposal as a complete portfolio strategy.

Key ideas

  • The problem allocates a finite budget across multiple independent investment opportunities.
  • The response suggests maximizing the sum of probability-weighted log payoffs across investments.
  • The question differs from single-bet Kelly sizing and mutually exclusive betting models.
  • Uncertain return parameters and changing conditions over time are left unresolved.
  • Allocation constraints and the intended return objective require further specification.

Tags

Full text
# Optimal investment strategy problem with competing bet-sizing options and limited budget


# Optimal investment strategy problem with competing bet-sizing options and limited budget












Apologies for a potentially naive question and unusual wording. I am from another field and would be very grateful for help!

I am looking for the optimal investment strategy that maximizes an overall expected return with multiple uncertain invest events and stochastic returns. Let strategy/portfolio $\mathcal{S} = \{b_1,b_2,...,b_n\}$ be a tuple of $n$ invests and $\sum_i b_i = B$ the investor's budget. The uncertainty that an invest occurs is characterized by probability $p_i$ where all invest events are mutually independent. If invest $b_i$ occurs, its return is $r_i = f_i(b_i)$ with $f_i(.)$ being a known mapping with uncertain parameters $\theta_i$. Returns are mutually uncorrelated.

My question is:

How to solve for the optimal strategy/portfolio $\mathcal{S^*}$ that maximizes the overall expected return $R^*$ under budget $B$ in a sequence of investment decisions?

As far as I understand, the Kelly criterion is similar in that it gives an optimal bet sizing strategy to invest wager $b$ with payoff odds given as a fraction of the invest (i.e. $f(b)$ is a linear function with zero intercept), and that there is only a payoff with probability $p$. It differs, however, in that it assumes a single invest, whereas here we have $n$ competing investment options under a limited budget. The extension by Smoczynski and Tomkins (2010) is unsuitable as it considers mutually exclusive investments, such as in horse races, where our problem has mutually independent investments. Also, in our problem, and unlike some portfolio choice problems, the investor has no option to divest e.g. into a risk-free asset.

I am also unsure about the treatment of time. Similar to the Kelly criterion and intertemporal portfolio choice problems, where bets are placed over a sequence of runs, in this problem, the investor has to continuously take decisions as parameters $\theta$, returns $r$ and the budget $B$ change (asynchronously) over time.

My application is a research portfolio for which I seek a soundly derivable strategy to distribute head count on research topics.

## Answer by Igor Rivin (score 1)

https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/59195

If I understand correctly, you are looking for the optimal allocation $b_1, \dotsc, b_n$. You can compute the expected log return for each asset - it is $p_i \log f(b_i),$ so you optimize the sum $\sum_i p_i \log f(b_i).$ I am not sure what you mean by "uncertain parameters".

Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)

This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.