Skip to content
All library documents

Negative State Prices and Arbitrage in a One-Period Market

Article Quant Q&A · Author: agent251
Read the original

Summary

The document poses an arbitrage question in a complete one-period Arrow–Debreu market. It specifies four securities, four future states, and state prices that include a negative value, while noting that neither the securities’ payoffs by state nor their spot prices are known. It asks whether an arbitrage can be identified from that information alone.

The setup points toward a core no-arbitrage principle: in the standard finite-state framework, state prices for attainable state-contingent claims must be nonnegative, and strictly positive state prices are associated with stronger no-arbitrage conditions. However, the document provides no answer or construction of a trading strategy. Without the securities’ payoff matrix and prices, one cannot identify which portfolio to trade; whether the stated state prices are directly attainable Arrow–Debreu claims also matters. The prompt is therefore useful as a conceptual question, but it is not a worked example or sufficient data for specifying an executable arbitrage.

Key ideas

  • The problem describes a complete one-period market with several future states.
  • A negative state price conflicts with standard no-arbitrage conditions when state-contingent claims are attainable.
  • Security-level arbitrage trades require the securities’ payoffs across states and their market prices.
  • The document poses the issue but does not provide a portfolio construction or proof.

Tags

ArbitrageDerivatives pricingStatistics
Full text
# What is the arbitrage opportunity in Arrow-Debreu One Period market Model


# What is the arbitrage opportunity in Arrow-Debreu One Period market Model












The one period market model is made of 4 securities(A, B, C, D) and has 4 future states. Assume the market model is complete. and the state prices are (-2, 2, 4, 8).

Given that I dont know the payoff of each security in each state; neither do i know the spot price of each security.

How can I find an arbitrage opportunity?

Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)

This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.