Persistent Slots with Rolling Score Entries and Signal-Based Exits
Summary
This document presents an event-driven method for holding a limited number of intraday positions. Predictions are aligned to price bars using the latest available score, subject to an optional freshness limit. Entry signals use a rolling quantile computed separately for each asset, addressing differences in score distributions. New qualifying candidates are ranked by score and admitted until the slot limit is reached; each open slot receives a fixed weight.
Positions can close when they reach a maximum holding period, when the score falls below a per-asset stay threshold, or when an optional take-profit or stop-loss level is hit. The simulator tracks entry prices and gives exits a defined priority, then emits weights for currently held assets. The text reports a sandbox finding that signal exits and take-profit exits each helped out of sample, while combining them did not; callers are therefore directed to test them as separate variants. That finding is scoped to the cited case study, and the excerpt does not provide detailed performance figures. The method is long-only or short-only, and relies on valid aligned predictions and prices for the relevant exit rules.
Key ideas
- Backward as-of alignment maps each price bar to the freshest available prediction within an optional age limit.
- Per-asset rolling quantiles determine entry signals and can provide lower stay thresholds for signal exits.
- A slot limit controls concurrent positions, while candidates are chosen by descending score and assigned fixed weights.
- Slots can exit through maximum holding time, a score threshold, take-profit, or stop-loss rules.
- The cited sandbox reports benefits from signal exits or take-profit individually, but not from stacking both.
Tags
Full text
# slot_strategy.py
```py
"""Persistent-slot signal-exit strategy for intraday execution.
The slot mechanism is the operationally-defensible variant of the canonical
``eq_w_topk`` selection used in chapters 11-19. It is designed for
microstructure case studies (nasdaq100) where:
- predictions arrive at one cadence (e.g. 1-min) but execution rebalances
on a coarser cadence (e.g. 15-min)
- per-symbol score distributions are heterogeneous (a 0.6 score for AAPL
is not equivalent to a 0.6 score for AMZN), so entry uses a per-symbol
rolling quantile rather than cross-sectional rank
- the chapter narrative needs a *signal-based exit* — close positions
when the score crosses back below a stay-threshold — which neither
``eq_w_topk`` nor ``risk_controls.position`` (Ch19) expresses
Mechanism:
1. Align predictions to price-grid timestamps via backward asof (freshest
prediction within ``pred_freshness_max_min``).
2. Compute per-symbol rolling entry threshold at quantile ``long_q``
(delegates to ``signals.per_symbol_rolling_percentile_signal``).
3. Optionally compute per-symbol rolling stay threshold at quantile
``exit_signal_q`` < ``long_q``.
4. Walk bars in time order maintaining ``open_slots: dict[sym -> entry_bar]``.
At each bar:
(a) close slots whose age >= ``hold_bars`` (max-hold backstop)
(b) close slots whose current score < stay_threshold (signal-exit)
(c) close slots hitting ``take_profit`` / ``stop_loss`` vs entry price
(d) open new slots from the top ``max_slots - len(open_slots)`` entries
sorted by score descending
(e) emit ``weight_per_slot`` for every currently-held (ts, sym)
Take-profit and stop-loss are per-slot exit legs evaluated against each
slot's entry price. They are an intrinsic property of the slot mechanism's
event-driven holding period (entry -> exit on the FIRST trigger), distinct
from Ch19 ``risk_controls.position`` overlays which act on a continuously
rebalanced weight series. The sandbox finding (nasdaq100 v4) is that
signal-exit OR take-profit each help out-of-sample but stacking them does
not, so callers sweep them as mutually exclusive exit variants.
The output schema ``[timestamp, symbol, weight]`` is what
``backtest_runner._run_engine`` consumes as ``weights``.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from collections.abc import Mapping
from datetime import datetime
from typing import Literal
import polars as pl
from case_studies.utils.signals import per_symbol_rolling_percentile_signal
def _run_slot_simulation(
signals_by_ts: dict[datetime, list[tuple[str, float]]],
all_bars_sorted: list[datetime],
max_slots: int,
weight_per_slot: float,
hold_bars: int,
*,
score_by_ts_sym: Mapping[tuple[datetime, str], float] | None,
stay_threshold_by_ts_sym: Mapping[tuple[datetime, str], float] | None,
price_by_ts_sym: Mapping[tuple[datetime, str], float] | None = None,
take_profit: float | None = None,
stop_loss: float | None = None,
) -> tuple[pl.DataFrame, dict]:
"""Pure-mechanism slot simulator with optional signal-exit and TP/SL.
Walks ``all_bars_sorted`` in order. Returns long-only weights frame and
a stats dict with per-exit-cause counts. Exit priority per bar:
max-hold, then signal-exit, then take-profit, then stop-loss. TP/SL
compare the current bar's price to the slot's entry price and require
``price_by_ts_sym``; absent a current/entry price the TP/SL legs are
skipped (the slot still honours max-hold/signal-exit).
"""
if max_slots <= 0:
raise ValueError(f"max_slots must be positive, got {max_slots}")
if hold_bars <= 0:
raise ValueError(f"hold_bars must be positive, got {hold_bars}")
if not (0 < weight_per_slot <= 1.0):
raise ValueError(f"weight_per_slot must be in (0, 1], got {weight_per_slot}")
if stop_loss is not None and stop_loss < 0:
raise ValueError(f"stop_loss must be positive (sign applied internally), got {stop_loss}")
if take_profit is not None and take_profit <= 0:
raise ValueError(f"take_profit must be positive, got {take_profit}")
score_lookup = score_by_ts_sym or {}
stay_lookup = stay_threshold_by_ts_sym or {}
price_lookup = price_by_ts_sym or {}
use_tp_sl = take_profit is not None or stop_loss is not None
open_slots: dict[str, dict] = {} # sym -> {"entry_i", "entry_px"}
rows: list[dict] = []
n_entries = 0
n_exits_maxhold = 0
n_exits_signal = 0
n_exits_tp = 0
n_exits_sl = 0
for i, ts in enumerate(all_bars_sorted):
# 1. Expire slots — max-hold, then signal-exit, then TP, then SL
to_close: list[tuple[str, str]] = []
for sym, slot in open_slots.items():
if i - slot["entry_i"] >= hold_bars:
to_close.append((sym, "maxhold"))
continue
key = (ts, sym)
current_score = score_lookup.get(key)
stay_thresh = stay_lookup.get(key)
if (
current_score is not None
and stay_thresh is not None
and current_score < stay_thresh
):
to_close.append((sym, "signal"))
continue
if use_tp_sl and slot["entry_px"] is not None:
current_px = price_lookup.get(key)
if current_px is not None and slot["entry_px"] > 0:
ret = current_px / slot["entry_px"] - 1.0
if take_profit is not None and ret >= take_profit:
to_close.append((sym, "tp"))
continue
if stop_loss is not None and ret <= -stop_loss:
to_close.append((sym, "sl"))
continue
for sym, cause in to_close:
del open_slots[sym]
if cause == "maxhold":
n_exits_maxhold += 1
elif cause == "signal":
n_exits_signal += 1
elif cause == "tp":
n_exits_tp += 1
else:
n_exits_sl += 1
# 2. New entries — sorted by score desc, capacity-limited
candidates = signals_by_ts.get(ts, [])
if candidates:
fresh = [(s, sc) for s, sc in candidates if s not in open_slots]
fresh.sort(key=lambda x: -x[1])
capacity = max_slots - len(open_slots)
for sym, _score in fresh[:capacity]:
entry_px = price_lookup.get((ts, sym)) if use_tp_sl else None
open_slots[sym] = {"entry_i": i, "entry_px": entry_px}
n_entries += 1
# 3. Emit weights for currently-held symbols
for sym in open_slots:
rows.append({"timestamp": ts, "symbol": sym, "weight": weight_per_slot})
stats = {
"n_entries": n_entries,
"n_exits_maxhold": n_exits_maxhold,
"n_exits_signal": n_exits_signal,
"n_exits_tp": n_exits_tp,
"n_exits_sl": n_exits_sl,
"n_exits_total": n_exits_maxhold + n_exits_signal + n_exits_tp + n_exits_sl,
"max_slots": max_slots,
"hold_bars": hold_bars,
"n_bars": len(all_bars_sorted),
}
if not rows:
empty = pl.DataFrame(
schema={"timestamp": pl.Datetime("us"), "symbol": pl.String, "weight": pl.Float64}
)
return empty, stats
out = pl.DataFrame(rows).with_columns(pl.col("timestamp").cast(pl.Datetime("us")))
return out, stats
def _align_predictions_to_bars(
predictions: pl.DataFrame,
bar_grid: pl.DataFrame,
*,
pred_freshness_max_min: int | None,
score_col: str,
time_col: str,
asset_col: str,
) -> pl.DataFrame:
"""Backward-asof align predictions to a (symbol, timestamp) bar grid.
``bar_grid`` carries the rebalance schedule. For each (sym, bar_ts) row,
pull the freshest prediction with timestamp <= bar_ts and stale by at
most ``pred_freshness_max_min`` minutes. Predictions older than the
tolerance are dropped, leaving rows with null ``y_score`` which are
then filtered out.
When ``pred_freshness_max_min`` is None, the asof tolerance is
unbounded (typical when predictions and prices share the same cadence).
"""
bars = bar_grid.select([asset_col, time_col]).sort([asset_col, time_col])
preds = predictions.select([asset_col, time_col, score_col]).sort([asset_col, time_col])
tol = f"{pred_freshness_max_min}m" if pred_freshness_max_min is not None else None
aligned = bars.join_asof(
preds,
on=time_col,
by=asset_col,
strategy="backward",
tolerance=tol,
)
return aligned.filter(pl.col(score_col).is_not_null()).sort([asset_col, time_col])
def _signals_to_lookup(
signals_df: pl.DataFrame,
*,
score_col: str,
time_col: str,
asset_col: str,
) -> dict[datetime, list[tuple[str, float]]]:
"""Convert ``per_symbol_rolling_percentile_signal`` output (signal==1 rows)
to ``dict[ts -> list[(sym, score)]]`` for the slot simulator.
"""
fired = signals_df.filter(pl.col("signal") == 1).select([time_col, asset_col, score_col])
out: dict[datetime, list[tuple[str, float]]] = {}
for row in fired.iter_rows(named=True):
ts = row[time_col]
if ts not in out:
out[ts] = []
out[ts].append((row[asset_col], float(row[score_col])))
return out
def build_persistent_slot_weights_hybrid(
predictions: pl.DataFrame,
prices: pl.DataFrame,
*,
long_q: float,
lookback_days: int,
bars_per_day: int,
max_slots: int,
hold_bars: int,
weight_per_slot: float | None = None,
exit_signal_q: float | None = None,
take_profit: float | None = None,
stop_loss: float | None = None,
pred_freshness_max_min: int | None = None,
direction: Literal["long_only", "short_only"] = "long_only",
score_col: str = "y_score",
time_col: str = "timestamp",
asset_col: str = "symbol",
price_col: str = "close",
) -> tuple[pl.DataFrame, dict]:
"""Library entry point for the persistent-slot signal-exit selection method.
Pipeline:
1. Align ``predictions`` to ``prices`` grid via backward-asof.
2. Compute per-symbol rolling entry threshold at ``long_q``; entry signal
where y_score > threshold.
3. If ``exit_signal_q`` is set (< ``long_q``), compute per-symbol rolling
stay threshold at that quantile.
4. Run slot simulation with ``max_slots`` capacity and ``hold_bars`` cap,
plus optional ``take_profit`` / ``stop_loss`` per-slot exit legs
(evaluated on the bar-close return vs the slot's entry price).
5. Apply ``direction`` sign — ``short_only`` flips the weight sign.
``take_profit`` / ``stop_loss`` are decimals (0.005 = 0.5%). They free the
slot on trigger so the weight series stops emitting the symbol until a fresh
entry signal — the slot-native re-entry semantics that engine-level
``risk_controls.position`` rules cannot express against a dense target
series. The nasdaq100 v4 sandbox finding is that signal-exit OR take-profit
each help out-of-sample but stacking them does not, so callers pass at most
one of ``exit_signal_q`` / ``take_profit`` per configuration.
Returns ``(weights_df, stats_dict)``. ``weights_df`` has schema
``[timestamp, symbol, weight]`` matching ``_run_engine`` input.
Note: long_short is not supported — slot books are inherently
single-direction (a symbol cannot occupy a long and short slot
simultaneously). The cross-asset long-short story belongs to
``eq_w_topk`` / ``quintile_long_short``.
"""
if direction not in ("long_only", "short_only"):
raise ValueError(
f"slot direction must be 'long_only' or 'short_only', got {direction!r}; "
"long_short is not supported for the slot mechanism"
)
if exit_signal_q is not None and exit_signal_q >= long_q:
raise ValueError(
f"exit_signal_q ({exit_signal_q}) must be < long_q ({long_q}) "
"so the stay threshold sits below the entry threshold"
)
if weight_per_slot is None:
weight_per_slot = 1.0 / max_slots
aligned = _align_predictions_to_bars(
predictions,
prices,
pred_freshness_max_min=pred_freshness_max_min,
score_col=score_col,
time_col=time_col,
asset_col=asset_col,
)
sig_df = per_symbol_rolling_percentile_signal(
aligned,
long_q=long_q,
lookback_days=lookback_days,
bars_per_day=bars_per_day,
score_col=score_col,
time_col=time_col,
asset_col=asset_col,
signal_type="long_only",
stay_q=exit_signal_q,
)
signals_by_ts = _signals_to_lookup(
sig_df,
score_col=score_col,
time_col=time_col,
asset_col=asset_col,
)
if exit_signal_q is not None:
stay_lookup = {
(r[time_col], r[asset_col]): float(r["stay_thresh"])
for r in sig_df.filter(pl.col("stay_thresh").is_not_null())
.select([time_col, asset_col, "stay_thresh"])
.iter_rows(named=True)
}
score_lookup = {
(r[time_col], r[asset_col]): float(r[score_col])
for r in aligned.select([time_col, asset_col, score_col]).iter_rows(named=True)
}
else:
stay_lookup = None
score_lookup = None
if take_profit is not None or stop_loss is not None:
price_lookup = {
(r[time_col], r[asset_col]): float(r[price_col])
for r in prices.select([time_col, asset_col, price_col])
.filter(pl.col(price_col).is_not_null())
.iter_rows(named=True)
}
else:
price_lookup = None
schedule = sorted(aligned[time_col].unique().to_list())
weights, stats = _run_slot_simulation(
signals_by_ts=signals_by_ts,
all_bars_sorted=schedule,
max_slots=max_slots,
weight_per_slot=weight_per_slot,
hold_bars=hold_bars,
score_by_ts_sym=score_lookup,
stay_threshold_by_ts_sym=stay_lookup,
price_by_ts_sym=price_lookup,
take_profit=take_profit,
stop_loss=stop_loss,
)
if direction == "short_only" and not weights.is_empty():
weights = weights.with_columns((-pl.col("weight")).alias("weight"))
stats["direction"] = direction
stats["long_q"] = long_q
stats["exit_signal_q"] = exit_signal_q
stats["take_profit"] = take_profit
stats["stop_loss"] = stop_loss
return weights, stats
```Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: MIT
This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.