Trading Volatility Forecasts Against Implied Volatility
Summary
The document discusses how a forecast of next-day realized stock volatility might inform an options position. It presents long straddles as a way to benefit from large moves and short straddles as a way to collect option premium when volatility is expected to be low. It also notes that a volatility view alone does not determine whether the trade has an edge: a buyer should compare forecast realized volatility with the volatility implied by current option prices.
The responses point to delta-neutral at-the-money straddles as a starting structure, while emphasizing that implied volatility changes over time and that a one-day forecast may not describe the path relevant to an option's life. Variance swaps and volatility-linked products are mentioned as alternatives, with pricing complexity noted for volatility indexes and related instruments. Liquidity, transaction costs, entry and exit costs, and other risks also affect the trade. The discussion is theoretical and provides no sizing rule, pricing model, or empirical strategy results.
Key ideas
- A volatility forecast can motivate long or short straddles depending on the expected size of realized moves.
- Compare forecast realized volatility with option implied volatility before deciding whether to buy or sell volatility.
- Delta neutrality and strike selection matter when constructing a straddle.
- A one-day forecast may be insufficient because implied volatility varies across the option's life.
- Transaction costs, liquidity, and other risks can erase an apparent volatility edge.
Tags
Full text
# How to trade volatility? # How to trade volatility? I am analyzing the volatility of financial stock returns and let's say I have a pretty good model to forecast tomorrows volatility of the stock returns. So let's say for simplicity reasons I have a GARCH(1,1). With this model I forecasted the volatility tomorrow and I now want to trade on it. The volatility tells me how much the stock returns and therefore the stock itself will "change"/fluctuate. If I have the volatility and if I am pretty sure about the probability of my correctness, how should I trade this? Should I e.g. invest in a straddle? And if yes, how should I determine the optimal options/ options conditions I should use? EDIT: So my basic question is: I have the value for the volatility forecast and I know that there are certain option-combinations to trade on high and low volatility, but how can I connect these strategies to my forecasted value, to my real value I calculated? ## Answer by Gabriel Vonlanten C. Lopes (score 2) https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/9781 Since you are talking about using volatility of stocks you could just use the straddle strategy both on long or short. I will answer only with theory about trading strategies. If you are 100% certain (we know this is not possible, but let´s take this as an assumption just for the sake of theory matter) of the volatily you can go two ways: High Volatility: You will be long on a straddle, this means you would buy a call and a put option with similar prices to take advantage of any direction Low Volatility: You can be short on a straddle, this means you would sell both call an put option with really similar prices and earn the premium of the options. ## Answer by experquisite (score 2) https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/9783 One thing that is missing from this discussion - only buy the straddle if your forecast for future realized volatility is higher than the implied volatility for which the straddles are currently selling. Nonetheless, having a one-day-ahead forecast isn't much good without knowing at least the expected path of implied volatility priced into options, for the implied volatility is not a constant. When buying or selling your straddle, you'll want to make sure that it is delta-neutral. That is how you pick the strike, or time the purchases. As for what other instruments work better, there are broker-quoted "variance swaps", which are linear derivatives on the future realized variance. It might also be worthwhile to look into listed ETPs on various volatility indexes like the VIX, or VIX futures themselves if you are comfortable with them. There are numerous subtleties to VIX index pricing, and all the related indices. ## Answer by FindTheFlow (score 0) https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/9812 Don't forget about liquidity holes and transaction costs. You can use more complicated structures, to trade volatility; however, they all come with their own issues. You do need to focus on all the costs and calculate your edge against your forecast and both the entry and exit for the straddles plus possible other risk factors. Focus on ATM straddles to begin with.
Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)
This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.