Valuing a Loan Facility with Fixed and Floating Rate Choices
Summary
The document considers a borrower’s option to choose between a fixed-rate loan, a floating-rate loan, or cancellation after a decision window. It frames the choices as embedded options with value linked to the borrower’s credit spread, interest rates, and the penalty for cancelling. The response describes the fixed-rate choice as resembling a bond call option and the floating-rate choice as resembling an option to sell credit protection on the borrower or collateral.
For valuation, it identifies credit spread and spread volatility as important inputs for the floating-rate component, while bond price volatility reflects both rates and credit spreads for the fixed-rate component. It suggests using swaption volatility in a Black-style model for the fixed-loan option when credit spreads are assumed constant. The response offers the greater of the two option values as a simplifying approximation for their joint value, while warning that this understates value. It does not provide a full calibrated model or worked numerical valuation.
Key ideas
- The loan choices can be viewed as embedded options on fixed and floating loan value.
- The floating-rate choice depends on the borrower’s credit spread and its volatility.
- The fixed-rate choice resembles an option on a bond, with value affected by rates and credit spreads.
- Using the larger of the two separate option values is a simplifying approximation that understates joint value.
- Swaption volatility can help estimate bond price volatility when credit spreads are treated as constant.
Tags
Full text
# Option on Loan rate
# Option on Loan rate
I have been trying to get my head around pricing an option none of the traditional option types fit the structure.
I want to get a loan of $100 , 5Y maturity . The lender gives me the following terms.
- On day 1 there is a fixed rate offer on the table . Lets say 2.5% .
- Once locked in I have 6 months to decide if I want the loan.
- End of this period I can either accept the terms or reject it. No penalty.
- If I accept it , I have a 30 day option(European for simplicity sake) where I can either take this loan at 2.5% , take the prevailing USD Libor + 50 bps or pay a penalty and cancel the facility.
Essentially it is 30 day option on Loan rate , of notional $100 and tenor 5Y and the penalty is the embedded option premium and option can be represented as min(2.5%,3M Libor+50) . Whats the best way of pricing this penalty i.e the embedded option premium.
I will update if I find a solution , in the meantime any thoughts will great.
## Answer by Ami44 (score 2)
https://quant.stackexchange.com/a/32538
Combining the 2 Options
- The option on the floating rate loan is comparable to an option to sell credit protection on yourself (or your collateral).
- To value the option on the fixed loan you have to take interest and credit spread into consideration. It's comparable to a call option on a bond.
These two options are not independent since you can exercise maximal one of them and never both. As an approximation you can simply use the higher value of the two options as joint option value. Note that this will always underestimate the real value.
Payouts:
In the first 6 month your payout is $$\max(NPV(250bp), NPV(Libor + 50bp), 0)$$ where $NPV(250bp)$ is meant to be the present value of the loan with 2.5% fixed rate and $NPV(Libor + 50bp)$ the present value of the floating rate loan. Note that I understand the $NPV$ from your perspective. Hence I used maximum and not minimum to describe the payout.
After you agreed to the loan in the 30 days period the payout becomes $$\max(NPV(250bp), NPV(Libor + 50bp), -p) = \max(NPV(250bp+s_{p}), NPV(Libor + 50bp+s_{p}), 0) - p$$ with $s_{p}$ being the penalty $p$ expressed as a running spread. So I think you are right, in that you can see $p$ as an option premium, but it is an premium that is payed at maturity and you have to add $s_{p}$ on the coupon of the underlying loan.
Price option 1
Pricing of CDS Options
To price a CDS Option you need to know
- credit spread or CDS spread of yourself (or of your collateral).
- determine a volatility of your credit spread
The first bullet point seems the more inmportant one, it allows you to calculate the intrinsic value of the option. You can get an idea of your credit spread if you shop around a bit and get some offers without optional components.
The second part is more challenging, you need some history to determine a volatility. Otherwise you can not calculate a time value.
Price option 2
To value an option on a fixed bond you also need your current credit spread to determine the intrinsic value and some volatility of the bond price, which is determined by credit spread and interest movement.
Calculate Bond price volatility
Often in these cases the credit spread is assumed to be constant, which reduces option 1 to it's intrinsic value and option 2 can be calculated with the black model using available volatilities for swaptions.Shown in full with attribution under the source's licence. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 (Stack Exchange)
This summary was written by Stratmill's research agent from the original; it is not a copy of the source.