Strategies
DOT USD-M Daily Time-Series Momentum, Long-Short with Long-Term Regime Filter (Single-Instrument BINANCE Perp, Pure OHLCV, Validated-Family Trend Edge Extended to a Decorrelated, Deep-History L1 Major, Wide ATR Stop, Low-Parameter)
Outcome: Abandoned
DOTDailyTimeSeriesMomentumRegimeFilteredLS
Outcome Summary
DOTDailyTimeSeriesMomentumRegimeFilteredLS extended the promoted BTC/ETH/SOL daily TS-momentum family to DOT, a deep-history decorrelated L1, adding a 200-day rising/falling regime-and-slope gate specifically to dodge the chop that killed the LTC trend extension. The design was clean and well-sampled, but DOT traded like a range-bound laggard: longs were entered in 'confirmed uptrends' and chopped to a 5.9% win rate, producing profit factor 0.55, -$836 expectancy, and a -28.8% net result with a 61% drawdown across multiple regimes. The analyst verified there was no polarity bug and ruled it a genuine absence of trend edge — the family does not generalize to non-clean-trending majors regardless of the slope filter or tuning. It ended after one iteration as abandoned, never advancing to optimization or risk review.
Hypothesis
Implementation
Long-short, single-instrument DAILY time-series momentum on DOTUSDT.BINANCE (USD-M perpetual) using the validated price-vs-moving-average trend family. The continuous signal is (close - 50d SMA)/|50d SMA|. A long-term 200-day regime filter (price above a RISING 200d MA for longs, below a FALLING 200d MA for shorts) gates all entries, keeping the book flat during directionless transitions. Exits on a wide 4*ATR stop, a momentum (signal-sign) flip, or a regime flip (price crossing back through the 200d MA). Pure OHLCV, no supplementary data, single-venue/single-account, ~6 low-overfit knobs. Sizes 50% of equity notional per leg at leverage 1.0.
Backtest Review
- Sharpe
- -0.37
- Total return
- -29.60%
- Max drawdown
- 61.27%
- Trades
- 60
- Win rate
- 25.0%
- Profit factor
- 0.55
Clean single-instrument/single-venue/single-account, pure-OHLCV design that avoids the multi-leg and supplementary-data landmines flagged elsewhere
Deep multi-regime history (2020-2026, 60 trades) so the negative result is well-sampled, not a thin fluke
Low fee drag (commission 3.25% of gross) — losses are signal-driven, not cost-driven
Structurally losing: total_return -28.8%, Sharpe -0.37, profit_factor 0.55, omega 0.76, expectancy -$836/trade, win_rate 25%, max_drawdown 61%, 15 consecutive losses
Long leg is broken: long_win_rate 5.9% (1 of 17) — the exact LTC-style whipsaw (16.8% win rate) the hypothesis claimed the regime/slope filter would prevent; the gate did not stop it
No edge across regimes: annual returns net negative and inconsistent (2021 -62%, 2024 -17%, 2025 -21%; only 2022/2026 positive) over 5+ years — the span meant to validate the edge instead invalidates it
DOT behaves like a range-bound laggard (the LTC failure profile), not a clean-trending major; entry polarity checks out, so this is genuine lack of edge, not a fixable bug
Outcome Summary
The daily trend-following edge is asset-specific to clean trenders (BTC/ETH/SOL) and does not generalize to range-bound L1 laggards: DOT reproduced the LTC failure (5.9% long win rate, negative expectancy across every regime) and a 200-day regime + slope chop filter did not prevent the whipsaw — screening for a decorrelated narrative is not a substitute for verified trend persistence on the specific asset.
It was abandoned at the pre-optimization backtest-review gate (verdict: abandon) because the validated daily-trend edge does not extend to DOT — a genuine lack of edge (entry polarity verified, no bug) across multiple real regimes with a catastrophic 5.9% long win rate, exactly the LTC whipsaw the regime/slope filter was meant to prevent — so with profit factor 0.55 and no robust region to tune, optimization and all later stages were never reached.
A single-instrument, single-venue long/short daily time-series momentum strategy on DOTUSDT.BINANCE USD-M perps — trading the price-vs-MA50 trend sign, gated by a 200-day rising/falling regime-with-slope filter (long only above a rising MA200, short only below a falling MA200) with a wide ATR stop and momentum/regime-flip exits — extending the factory's validated daily-trend family to DOT as a decorrelated, deep-history L1 major, with the slope gate explicitly added to avoid the LTC chop-whipsaw.
Over 2020-2026 and 60 trades (17 long / 43 short) it was a structural loser: total return -28.8%, Sharpe -0.37, profit factor 0.55, omega 0.76, expectancy -$836/trade, win rate 25%, 61% max drawdown, 15 consecutive losses — with the long leg broken (long win rate 5.9%, 1 of 17) and net-negative inconsistent annual returns (2021 -62%, 2024 -17%, 2025 -21%; only 2022/2026 positive); fees were not the driver (commission 3.25% of gross).
Backtest and paper results are hypothetical. Trading involves risk of loss.