跳至正文
返回文库全部文档

用协方差惩罚降低回测过拟合

文章 arXiv papers · 作者: Adriano Koshiyama et al.

总结

本文考察基于历史数据选择策略如何导致误导性的绩效估计。研究提出协方差惩罚修正方法,通过考虑交易策略所依据的参数数量和数据量来降低风险指标。作者将这一方法与处理数据窥探、绩效估计偏高以及交叉验证评估的其他方法一并讨论。

实证研究在超过1,300种资产上比较了使用普通最小二乘法和全最小二乘法的协方差惩罚方法。报告结果支持使用协方差惩罚来缓解回测过拟合,并显示在该研究中全最小二乘法表现优于普通最小二乘法。文中未提供详细资产分类、绩效指标或实施指南,因此不能据此确定该修正方法对每种策略或数据集的效果。

核心观点

  • 回测中的参数选择可能让策略历史表现显得比实际更可靠。
  • 协方差惩罚会根据策略开发所用的参数和数据调整风险指标。
  • 研究在超过1,300种资产上比较了普通最小二乘法和全最小二乘法。
  • 报告结果倾向于全最小二乘法,但摘要对评估条件的说明有限。

标签

全文
# 1905.05023


# Avoiding Backtesting Overfitting by Covariance-Penalties: an empirical investigation of the ordinary and total least squares cases









Systematic trading strategies are rule-based procedures which choose portfolios and allocate assets. In order to attain certain desired return profiles, quantitative strategists must determine a large array of trading parameters. Backtesting, the attempt to identify the appropriate parameters using historical data available, has been highly criticized due to the abundance of misleading results. Hence, there is an increasing interest in devising procedures for the assessment and comparison of strategies, that is, devising schemes for preventing what is known as backtesting overfitting. So far, many financial researchers have proposed different ways to tackle this problem that can be broadly categorised in three types: Data Snooping, Overestimated Performance, and Cross-Validation Evaluation. In this paper, we propose a new approach to dealing with financial overfitting, a Covariance-Penalty Correction, in which a risk metric is lowered given the number of parameters and data used to underpins a trading strategy. We outlined the foundation and main results behind the Covariance-Penalty correction for trading strategies. After that, we pursue an empirical investigation, comparing its performance with some other approaches in the realm of Covariance-Penalties across more than 1300 assets, using Ordinary and Total Least Squares. Our results suggest that Covariance-Penalties are a suitable procedure to avoid Backtesting Overfitting, and Total Least Squares provides superior performance when compared to Ordinary Least Squares.

在遵守原作品许可的前提下,附作者信息全文展示。 许可协议: abstract CC0

此摘要由 Stratmill 研究智能体根据原文撰写,并非原文副本。